feat(observation): add domain-separated v3 successor schema representation - #45
seonghobae wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
…ation Represent PostgreSQL schema snapshots in a v3 successor form alongside the existing v2 evidence. Relations now retain their observed kind and source comment, schema-scoped domain and enum observations share the same authorized schema allowlist as tables, and column type bindings resolve by exact qualified name without consulting search_path. The v3 identity is domain-separated from v2 so equal object sets never collapse the two generations into one digest. Duplicate relations, domains, enums, type names, enum labels, and domain check constraints fail closed, as do unresolved qualified type bindings.
|
Important Review skippedAuto reviews are disabled on base/target branches other than the default branch. Please check the settings in the CodeRabbit UI or the ⚙️ Run configurationConfiguration used: Organization UI Review profile: CHILL Plan: Advanced Run ID: You can disable this status message by setting the Use the checkbox below for a quick retry:
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
|
You have reached your Codex usage limits for code reviews. You can see your limits in the Codex usage dashboard. |
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
현재 exact head 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a에서 두 건을 repair finding으로 유지합니다.
-
P0 — #6이 요구한 first-class index evidence가 successor representation에 없습니다. #6의 현재 P0 계약은 index key vs INCLUDE attributes, expression positions, partial predicates, NULL uniqueness, readiness/validity/liveness와 exact receipt coordinate를 보존하도록 요구합니다. 그러나 이 head의
PostgresSchemaSnapshotV3는 relations/domains/enums만 소유하고,SchemaObjectLocationKind도 Table/Column/Constraint/Domain/Enum만 있으며, digest와every_v3_evidence_kind_has_a_verified_receipt_coordinatetest에도 index가 없습니다. 따라서 이 PR을 #6 P0 전체 구현으로 간주하면 안 됩니다. 기존 delta는 보존하고IndexObservation(또는 동등한 first-class VO), index-specific identity/coordinate/receipt/digest framing 및 각 material index fact의 RED→GREEN을 추가해야 합니다. -
P1 —
DomainObservation.base_type은 exact qualified binding이라고 주장하지만 실제 resolution validation을 거치지 않습니다.canonicalize_snapshot_objects는 relation column의type_binding만pg_catalog또는 observed domain/enum에 resolve되는지 검사하고, 각 domain의base_type은 검사하지 않습니다. 따라서 allowed schema 안의 domain이public.missing_type같은 미관측 qualified base type을 가리켜도 snapshot/digest 생성이 가능합니다. 먼저DomainObservation::new("public", "event_status_kind", QualifiedTypeName::new("public", "missing_type")?)+ no matching domain/enum인 snapshot이UnknownTypeBinding으로 실패해야 한다는 executable RED를 추가하십시오. 이후 한 개의 exact qualified-type resolver/invariant를 column binding과 domain base binding에 함께 적용해search_path추론 없이 fail closed하도록 수리하는 것이 최소 causal fix입니다.
또한 PR body는 Draft, matching the stacked base라고 적혀 있지만 GitHub lifecycle은 현재 non-Draft입니다. Parent #6이 Draft이고 위 P0/P1이 남아 있으므로 lifecycle도 Draft로 되돌리는 것이 맞습니다. 기존 local Rust 1.98 결과는 이 exact source에 대한 유용한 evidence이지만, 위 source repair 이후 새 exact head에서 다시 실행되어야 하며 predecessor GREEN을 승계하면 안 됩니다.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
추가 DDD/coordinate invariant finding입니다.
P1 — RelationObservation의 UL과 SchemaObjectLocation의 UL이 어긋나고, 현재 Table receipt가 non-table relation에도 발급됩니다. RelationObservation은 View, MaterializedView, Sequence, CompositeType까지 표현하지만 successor location은 여전히 SchemaObjectLocationKind::Table / SchemaObjectElement::Table / /schemas/{schema}/tables/{name}뿐입니다. 더 직접적으로 PostgresSchemaSnapshotV3::contains_location()의 Table branch는 relation name만 비교하고 RelationKind를 확인하지 않으므로, 예를 들어 audit_view()에 대해 SchemaObjectLocation::table("audit", "event_record")를 요청하면 table receipt가 성공합니다.
이 상태에서는 digest 안의 relation kind와 외부 provenance coordinate의 ubiquitous language가 서로 다른 truth를 말합니다. 두 방향 중 하나를 명시적으로 선택해 RED→repair 하십시오. (a) v3에서 generic Relation coordinate(/relations/…)와 필요하면 relation-child column/constraint coordinate를 도입하여 모든 relkind에 정확한 UL을 쓰거나, (b) Table coordinate를 실제 table-family에만 제한하고 view/materialized-view/sequence/composite-type용 versioned coordinate를 별도로 둡니다. 어느 쪽이든 frozen v2 /tables/… meaning은 변경하지 않아야 합니다.
RED에는 최소한 view/sequence snapshot이 Table kind receipt로 오인되지 않는 case와, 선택한 successor coordinate가 relation kind를 loss 없이 식별하는 case가 필요합니다. 이 finding도 first-class index 및 domain-base resolution과 함께 #45 Draft에서 먼저 해결하고 transport는 뒤로 유지하십시오.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination update: successor #46 now carries first-class index evidence plus shared domain-base resolution, but its current exact head 235ceda8f6d046a989d3955938a62dc67eb5ab09 is intentionally RED after review 5174516003. The new RED proves the index VO can encode contradictory key/INCLUDE roles and non-contiguous pg_index ordinals; #46 must repair that before its index delta can be treated as closing #45's P0. #45's separate relation-kind coordinate defect remains open unchanged. Preserve #45 Draft and stack order; do not transfer #46 predecessor local GREEN or retarget/flatten the stack.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination handoff: the three findings previously recorded against this parent (first-class index evidence, domain base-type resolution, and kind-accurate successor relation coordinates) now have ordinary forward source repairs in stacked #46. #46 is exact 033ae72b95e3ef490c47ec84c191b83632601b10, OPEN Draft, with current baseline authority. Its latest lineage additionally closes the impossible empty/INCLUDE-only index-state gap: review 5174770575 -> RED 808faa92... -> constructor/rustdoc repair 6dd59aef... -> baseline 033ae72b... -> exact-current review 5174799976. Keep #45 source stable; do not duplicate the child repair here. Parent adoption is sequenced only after #46 obtains fresh exact-head Rust 1.98 and applicable hosted Product/security/review acceptance, then ordinary/non-force integration preserves both histories.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination-only review on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: child #46 has advanced by ordinary forward history to 503a3c2d273f47a7b73f2eb7284826c5382f5a0a. The prior per-key PostgreSQL semantic RED is source/docs repaired there (173ae2f... production + 503a3c2d... baseline), but exact-head Rust/Product evidence is still absent. Preserve this parent source unchanged; do not duplicate the child implementation. Ordinary/non-force adoption becomes eligible only after #46 has one exact terminal GREEN head.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination-only review on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current child authority is #46 3a838d7acac79a69b2616fa74d77e3b66f34e013. Child review 5176253356 records source/docs repair for per-key semantics plus operator-class parameters, but exact-head native/Product GREEN is still absent (no PR workflow run; CodeRabbit-only combined status; no pinned Rust toolchain in the current runtime). Preserve the child delta without reimplementation. Do not restack/adopt into this parent until that exact child head is executable GREEN; when it is, use ordinary/non-force integration and regenerate parent evidence.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination authority refresh only; parent source remains unchanged. #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact 630040b71335b36095b1b10d262888fbb5bebd31. Its pg_index/operator-class/pg_class.reloptions repairs must be preserved. Current child blocker is review 5176975409 -> tablespace RED 1a47d6b16838006e5f7a75407e69464740f368b1; exact-current review 5177051047 records RED-active status. Do not reimplement in #45 or adopt early. Wait for #46 minimal IndexTablespace repair and one unchanged exact-head Rust/Product GREEN, then integrate ordinary/non-force and regenerate #45 acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination-only handoff: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact eaecb512aeee37eb53f9e5602b5466ab3e2de40d. The prior tablespace RED 1a47d6b... is now source-repaired by 5021ed6b... plus public export b56a38de...; eaecb512... currentizes the canonical baseline. Do not duplicate this child delta here. #46 is still Draft and lacks exact-head Rust/Product GREEN (no PR workflow runs; runtime has no Rust toolchain), so #45 must remain unchanged until the child obtains fresh acceptance, then adopt ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent evidence.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination update: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward from eaecb512... to exact 407434767187474fa7e497040ea2f29bffcd94e2. Preserve the child delta and do not reimplement it here. New review 5177806003 identifies missing index-object pg_class.relkind; RED d425bdfb00652321367dd1fef0c77930d2ade327 now requires ordinary (i) and partitioned (I) indexes to remain distinct v3 identities. 407434767... currentizes the canonical gap baseline. #46 is RED-active, not source/native/Product GREEN. Parent adoption remains blocked until that RED is minimally repaired and one unchanged #46 head obtains exact Rust/Product/security/review acceptance; then adopt ordinary/non-force into this parent.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination correction superseding review 5177824466: child #46's provisional index-relkind RED was invalid after deeper PostgreSQL 18 source verification. DefineIndex derives partitioned-index creation from the owning relation's partitioned-table kind and index_create deterministically maps that flag to RELKIND_PARTITIONED_INDEX versus ordinary RELKIND_INDEX. The same partitioned owning relation cannot validly choose both kinds as RED d425bdf... assumed. Child review 5177862263 records the correction; the RED was removed ordinary-forward at 96e2b683ad21ebdd1137f618b6f1d2c56ae544c2; current child is #46 exact 9ed1339e7251f74e423b90cd32c9503c821d53b2, source/docs repaired but still pending exact-head native/Product acceptance. Preserve this corrected child; do not add duplicate IndexRelationKind state in the parent.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh child handoff after corrected relkind analysis: #46 is now exact c73659fc5a94419018601407be628bc72ba9cd27. Review 5177885832 identifies a real PostgreSQL schema-local pg_class namespace gap; behavioral RED b820c7b80b6c95e6ae419515882d850d79e578ec requires snapshot construction to reject duplicate index names across two relations in one schema and index/relation name collisions, while allowing the same index name in different schemas. Preserve this child RED and do not reimplement it here. Parent adoption remains blocked until canonicalization repair plus one unchanged #46 head obtains exact Rust/Product/security/review GREEN.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: child #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to a548e7c811ea1037ce20343ac28f549eba8eb1ae. Namespace RED b820c7b... is source-repaired by 1bede235...; a548e7c... only currentizes the canonical baseline. Do not duplicate the child repair in this parent or adopt it before exact-head Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN. Parent remains Draft and unchanged.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Current child authority is #46 exact ebaff1d5307c3755b91d991b900cb18dd9bbb024. Preserve the child’s schema-local namespace and index-owner relation-kind repairs; do not duplicate them in this parent. Latest lineage is review 5178743508 -> RED f81ae51 -> production repair a8e9fac -> formatting successor ebaff1d -> exact-current review 5178790507. #46 still has zero PR-triggered workflow runs and only CodeRabbit success, so wait for unchanged exact-head Rust 1.98/Product/security/dependency/review terminal GREEN before ordinary/non-force adoption into #45. No predecessor evidence transfers.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Superseding child coordinate after ordinary-forward test formatting: #46 is now exact 9b77f3ff2f7f5cb2a10b233e9228f5885f72b70b. Preserve review 5178743508 -> RED f81ae51... -> repair a8e9fac... and the later formatting-only successors. The child remains Draft with zero PR-triggered workflow runs and CodeRabbit success only. Do not adopt into #45 until this exact successor obtains required Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN; then integrate ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination handoff on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current Source Observation repair successor is #46 exact 4826a66a50ef595453d8e2fc139e483334974063. Child lineage 5179341855 -> 089df3d4... RED -> 50b8d05e... source repair -> 4826a66a... baseline/current head -> review 5179398687 adds fail-closed represented constraint ownership by PostgreSQL relation kind. Do not reimplement this child delta here. Keep #45 Draft and adopt #46 ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head has repository-pinned Rust 1.98 and applicable Product/security/dependency/review GREEN; then regenerate parent exact-head acceptance before passing to #6.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination/current-authority review: #46 has advanced ordinary-forward to exact e2a5609cb9e6a7ced73b7069055adf151d8f7db1. Its new relation-backed composite type lineage is review 5180058119 -> RED eca8adb2e5667048c220a37ad863971a8457e9d3 -> source repair 66130c568705092ffd4dabc9bf56bf2a8c88da3a -> baseline currentization e2a5609c..., with exact-current review 5180159464. Preserve this child delta; do not duplicate it in #45. #46 still has zero PR-triggered workflow runs and no exact-head Rust/Product acceptance, so #45 must remain unchanged/Draft until the child obtains real exact-head GREEN, then adopt ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination/current-authority review: active child #46 is now exact fc373bb3cb0e658465d89389bfb08513703065f1, with PostgreSQL true-array identity finding 5180207753, RED 856934e561cf41b9ef546570b9a41524549b57f2, and exact-current RED review 5180249671. Preserve the child delta and do not duplicate it here. #45 remains unchanged/Draft; adoption is allowed only after #46 repairs first-class exact array/element identity and then produces real exact-head Rust 1.98/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current child authority is #46 89e571210336bada5eb033c983c8bf1fd1357464. The PostgreSQL true-array P1 remains child-owned. Finding 5180207753 produced initial RED 856934e5...; verification review 5180344773 found its _status collision fixture omitted the automatic array of that enum; corrected RED 51075e48... now uses catalog-realistic prior true-array occupancy and adds one-element/one-true-array plus no-array-of-array invariants; exact-current child review is 5180370943. Do not duplicate this delta in #45. Keep #45 Draft/unchanged until one repaired #46 exact head is Rust 1.98 + hosted Product/security/dependency/review GREEN, then adopt ordinary/non-force and regenerate parent acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination authority: current child #46 is a0f4766425dae85ffc63a735850455e76fcc7141. Its PostgreSQL true-array P1 is source/docs repaired through ArrayTypeObservation, array-aware admission/digest/receipt regressions and same-schema reciprocity, but exact-head Rust/Product acceptance is still absent. Keep this parent source head unchanged and Draft; do not reimplement the child delta here. Ordinary/non-force adoption starts only after #46 unchanged exact-head GREEN, followed by fresh #45 acceptance before #6 adoption.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination update on unchanged parent 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a: current repair successor is #46 exact ccd7e245010dab994a6540fe2de5e15db3f742ea. Child review 5180938301 -> RED 65be0a02... -> repair 27de693b... closes v3 admission of multiple primary keys and nullable primary-key columns without changing frozen v2 semantics; code-current baseline is ccd7e245... and exact-current child review is 5180986486. Do not duplicate this delta in #45 or adopt it before the child has unchanged-head native/Product acceptance. Protected/default ConceptWeave main still lacks the repository-local Product workflow bootstrap, so Ready/no-op/manual retriggers are not acceptance. Preserve ordinary/non-force order #46 GREEN -> #45 adoption/fresh acceptance -> #6.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint: parent source remains intentionally unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a; current child authority is #46 exact 1ecc9da762f7476d092b3d234d7bc4d15536999e, RED-active for constraint_backing_index_contract after the ordinary-forward PK/UNIQUE timing repair. Do not duplicate this child repair in #45 and do not transfer predecessor GREEN. Required sequence remains child causal repair -> unchanged exact-head Rust/Product/security/dependency/review GREEN -> ordinary/non-force adoption into #45 -> fresh parent acceptance -> #6.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh handoff after second ordinary-forward child repair: #46 exact 25508f53ed4ca8f4bb17b637dc82801ffcdbd7fc is now current complete child authority. New delta from 10c6c8c... is +6/−0 and preserves raw EXCLUDE pg_constraint.connoinherit via contract 3552cd38..., successor a605dd29..., export cd25d0aa..., doctoring e4c83d1f..., baseline 7f79bfb3..., CHANGELOG 25508f53.... Keep #45 source unchanged and do not partially adopt; native/hosted exact-head acceptance and PostgreSQL live differential remain required first.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh handoff after no-inherit lifecycle correction: current complete child authority is #46 exact 41a90acf08f3398e55f22298940745775ec9efc8. The child preserves raw connoinherit but no longer derives it from current parentage; pinned PostgreSQL attach/detach code proves both boolean values can be source-reachable for a current partition-child depending lifecycle. Keep #45 source unchanged; do not partially adopt before one unchanged #46 native+hosted terminal GREEN and concrete PostgreSQL 18 differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff checkpoint only; keep #45 source unchanged. Current complete child authority is #46 exact 658b46604edf597cac700175fc47b91200eaeed4, which adds ordinary EXCLUDE pg_constraint.conperiod evidence without rewriting predecessor digests. #46 is not GREEN (no repository-owned PR workflow run; no Rust toolchain here), so partial cherry-pick/reimplementation or adoption into this parent is not authorized. Adopt complete child ordinary/non-force only after central workflow/#35 prerequisites and one unchanged #46 native+hosted terminal GREEN plus live PostgreSQL differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff checkpoint: keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is now #46 exact 1051c8cddcd16bdb6d47bc5c2c13a7c736b2b859, including ordinary EXCLUDE pg_constraint.conkey preservation and the exact-predecessor repair from review 5219378111. Do not partially cherry-pick or reconstruct this delta here. Adoption remains ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head obtains native+hosted terminal acceptance and the PostgreSQL 18 live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff currentization only; keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is now #46 exact 3e57508fe488aa059122206a7f21a3576babbe63, with ordinary EXCLUDE pg_constraint.conexclop repair review 5219874038 and exact-head checkpoint 5219948193. Do not partially cherry-pick or independently reconstruct that child. Adoption remains complete ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head has native+hosted terminal GREEN and the PostgreSQL 18 live differential is complete.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Child-authority handoff checkpoint: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. The current complete Draft child is #46 exact a6698c423a15e1d268404588bbecf56d792ca009, which ordinary-forward adds PostgreSQL 18 ordinary EXCLUDE condeferrable ↔ exact conindid backing-index indimmediate coherence on top of all retained source repairs. Finding review 5220488022, exact-head checkpoint 5220554448. #46 is source/docs-current but not GREEN: no Rust toolchain is available here and fresh exact-head repository-owned PR workflow inventory is empty. Do not partially cherry-pick or reimplement this child; adoption remains complete ordinary/non-force only after unchanged-head native+hosted terminal acceptance and the bounded PostgreSQL live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff currentization only: keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is now #46 exact 0de651ee57f823638a416677239a9ef4dbac3c84, where ordinary EXCLUDE exact-conindid backing-index role coherence is source/docs-current (indisunique=false, indisprimary=false, indisexclusion=true; finding 5221108817, child checkpoint 5221146979). Do not partially adopt or reimplement this child delta. Ordinary/non-force adoption remains after unchanged-child native+hosted terminal acceptance and PostgreSQL 18 live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Child handoff currentization only; keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is #46 exact 250ed695fc36f83e97a26b004d1d7728712ef2cc, with relation-wide PostgreSQL 18 ordinary EXCLUDE conname integrity repaired for base PK/UQ/FK/CHECK and explicitly observed first-class NOT NULL evidence. Do not partially cherry-pick or reconstruct this delta here. Adoption remains ordinary/non-force only after the same child head receives native+hosted terminal GREEN and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff currentization only; keep #45 source unchanged. Current complete child authority is #46 exact fbb935ea1b7e6c17c81ebd9106cc8d6d20b55b5b, which ordinary-forward adds independent PostgreSQL 18 pg_constraint.connamespace evidence after review 5222226880. Do not partially cherry-pick or reimplement the namespace successor here. Adoption remains ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head has native+hosted terminal GREEN and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential independently reads connamespace and relation namespace before comparison.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff checkpoint only, not approval. Keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is #46 exact 9995a40ae33367ca0cd778740d02b6e55d937bcc, now including ordinary EXCLUDE catalog-family-shape repair review 5222790284. Do not partially cherry-pick or reimplement it here; ordinary/non-force adoption remains gated on unchanged-head native+hosted acceptance and the PostgreSQL 18 bounded live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Child-authority handoff: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. Complete current child authority is #46 exact 9cc1e8a2076cf329c043a4a77705cce4862b1faf, which ordinary-forward repairs PostgreSQL 18 ordinary-EXCLUDE constraint/backing-index name integrity under review 5223551886. Do not partially adopt or reimplement this delta. Adoption remains ordinary/non-force only after unchanged #46 receives Rust 1.98 native+hosted terminal GREEN and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff checkpoint: parent source remains unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a; current complete child authority is #46 exact 0578d70e684e8bf306b0642131aceca5ba16617b. The child ordinary-forward repair adds independently observed PostgreSQL EXCLUDE access-method can_exclude capability bound to the exact backing-index coordinate and AM name. Do not partially adopt this delta; ordinary/non-force complete child adoption remains gated on one unchanged #46 native+hosted terminal GREEN and bounded PostgreSQL 18 differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination handoff: current complete child authority is #46 exact 9ee431847d4814d8500d879d8e21134be1d7ec3b. The latest ordinary-forward repair governs independently observed PostgreSQL 18 pg_operator.oprcom per exact ordinary-EXCLUDE conexclop position and fails closed unless the resolved stable commutator signature is the exact same operator. This parent source remains intentionally unchanged; do not partially adopt or reimplement the child. Acceptance and live differential remain pending before ordinary/non-force parent adoption.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fresh parent handoff: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. Complete child authority is now #46 exact 573915a77cd85b66dd5f81bb802594a64c3f5318, which ordinary-forward adds independently resolved backing-index pg_class.relnamespace evidence after finding 5224968197. Do not partially adopt it. #46 still lacks lossless aggregate baseline/CHANGELOG currentization and exact-head native/hosted GREEN; adoption here remains ordinary/non-force only after those gates plus the bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint: keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority advanced ordinary-forward to #46 3296e5e6e735fa8f1c10dadc6387bd2e6682bf32; its backing-index namespace source repair and aggregate docs are now current, but it still lacks native/hosted terminal acceptance and the PostgreSQL 18 live differential. Do not partially adopt or independently reimplement child deltas. Adoption remains complete, ordinary, and non-force only after child acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Stack handoff currentization: keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is now #46 exact 742bef1a9c358e9bab123d4ec894289caa42b110, ordinary-forward from 3296e5e6.... New valid finding 5226246612 repaired ordinary-EXCLUDE backing-index lifecycle integrity: exact conindid now requires explicit pg_index.indisready=true, indisvalid=true, indislive=true in IndexExclusionConstraintIndexLifecycleSnapshot; missing/false lifecycle, wrong exact index, or source-generation mismatch fails closed. Lineage: structural RED 07fd2aec... -> production a4f5dff9... -> composition 203d3fe6... -> edge/provenance 5a11b4ca... -> doctoring facc961a... -> gap ffac2f6f... -> current 742bef1a.... No native/hosted GREEN exists on that child head. Adopt only after one unchanged accepted #46 head and PostgreSQL 18 differential independently reads ready/valid/live from the exact backing pg_index row; use ordinary/non-force adoption only.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Stack handoff currentization: keep #45 source unchanged. Complete child authority is #46 exact 84e287842d094755caa75272fae73111125fd3e7. The child now requires exact ordinary-EXCLUDE backing pg_index ready/valid/live evidence and exact v3 source-content generation identity. Follow-up review 5226362550 showed that matching source key/policy/extractor/time alone could mix lifecycle facts from a different content generation; 7d84bdbd... / c1561475... propagate the immutable v3 source digest and f7d8dbcf... enforces exact equality before lifecycle lookup. No predecessor digest calculation changed. Adopt only after one unchanged #46 head obtains native+hosted terminal acceptance and the PostgreSQL 18 differential independently proves backing namespace, ready/valid/live, and exact v3 generation; ordinary/non-force only.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Stack handoff only: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. Current complete child authority is #46 exact 3121fdf697217c2a53b245fe962f512bcbb64a5d, including the independent pg_operator.oprcode -> pg_proc ordinary-EXCLUDE procedure binding repair. Do not partially adopt; ordinary/non-force adoption waits for one unchanged child head with required native+hosted acceptance and PostgreSQL bounded differential evidence.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Final stack handoff for this pass: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. Current complete child authority is #46 exact 29d99055d349b06f0753a2c99e9516185c84ba77; its operator-procedure successor and dedicated contract are source/docs-current but not acceptance-complete. Ordinary/non-force adoption still waits for one unchanged #46 native+hosted GREEN plus the PostgreSQL live differential.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff checkpoint: source head remains unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a; current complete child authority is #46 exact 17a697f8b658d90f5c361a1abc489e4174df1429. The child now owns the ordinary-EXCLUDE pg_operator.oprresult / pg_proc.prorettype Boolean result-contract repair in addition to all retained predecessor semantics. Do not partially adopt or reimplement this delta here. Ordinary/non-force adoption remains gated on one unchanged child head receiving native+hosted terminal acceptance and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential closing.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint only; parent source remains unchanged. Complete Source Observation child authority has advanced ordinary-forward to #46 exact ef67a083c57f9dca142ce09b691a76fc5e1c03d3, adding the raw pg_operator.oprkind successor after the retained operator/result chain. Do not duplicate or partially cherry-pick that child repair here. Adoption remains ordinary/non-force only after one unchanged #46 head receives native+hosted terminal acceptance and its PostgreSQL 18 bounded differential closes. Parent exact-head evidence does not absorb child evidence.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Stack handoff checkpoint: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. Current complete child authority is #46 exact a1c23696f6db6faf6780446ecfac965ae309948d, including the ordinary-forward raw pg_proc.proretset=false enforcement-procedure successor and retained raw pg_operator.oprkind/result/procedure/catalog controls. #46 does not yet have exact-head native+hosted terminal GREEN or the bounded PostgreSQL 18 differential, so partial adoption or independent reimplementation here would violate the single-writer boundary. After child acceptance, adopt the complete valid delta ordinary/non-force and reacquire fresh #45 evidence.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handoff checkpoint: keep #45 source exact 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a unchanged. Complete child authority is now #46 exact fe69a28d229ee35b721e6b852631d07da9e19072, which adds lossless raw pg_proc.proisstrict evidence without inventing a strictness admission gate. Do not partially adopt or reimplement this delta. Ordinary/non-force adoption remains after one unchanged child head obtains native+hosted terminal GREEN and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 differential closes, including direct proisstrict resolution from the exact oprcode -> pg_proc row.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint only; no #45 source movement. Current child authority is #46 exact a27c69915d1e76af29752ad07b89b3fcdc9af22e, including the raw pg_proc.provolatile evidence successor. Keep this representation head unchanged until that exact child generation obtains native+hosted terminal GREEN and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential. Then adopt the complete valid child delta ordinary/non-force; partial cherry-pick or local reimplementation is not authorized.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint: keep #45 source unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a. Active child #46 is now exact 68ee4b2e852fb2f41750caa184f944d666bdf8a0 and adds observational raw PostgreSQL 18 pg_proc.proparallel (s|r|u) evidence over the exact procedure-volatility predecessor. #46 still lacks exact-head native/hosted GREEN and the bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential, so partial adoption, cherry-picking, or local reimplementation in #45 is not authorized. After child terminal acceptance, adopt the complete valid delta by ordinary/non-force integration and run fresh #45 acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint: #45 source remains intentionally unchanged at 6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a. Current complete child authority is #46 exact cc64bab7d81f2adb691f627e7de852ace6946227, including the new raw pg_proc.prokind='f' successor and retained proparallel/provolatile/proisstrict/proretset chain. No partial adoption is authorized. #46 still lacks exact-head Rust 1.98/hosted GREEN and the PostgreSQL 18 bounded live differential. Canonical .github#2106 also now has terminal Runtime Quality failure at its runtime-review start step, so owner repair plus fresh #35 acceptance remains prerequisite before complete ordinary/non-force child adoption.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Correction to the prior coordination checkpoint: fresh exact .github#2106@fdab6730... job-step inventory for Runtime Quality run 35145861624 shows failure at Verify scheduler and contextual-orchestrator review-repair contracts, not at runtime-review start. Subsequent DB-persistence, embedding-intent, OIDC-attestation, and runtime-review steps were skipped. The earlier failure-location wording is withdrawn; no narrower RCA is asserted without a specific failing assertion/log. #45 source remains unchanged, #46 authority remains cc64bab7d81f2adb691f627e7de852ace6946227, and complete ordinary/non-force adoption still waits for canonical owner repair, fresh #35 acceptance, and unchanged-head #46 native+hosted/live-differential GREEN.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Superseding correction from the second fresh exact .github#2106 run-job inventory: Runtime Quality run 35145861624, job 104961617955, fails at Verify scheduler and contextual-orchestrator review-repair contracts. Successful predecessors are runner hardening, exact PR-head checkout, Python/setup-suite selection, exact dependency installs, and the Noema token-lifetime contract. OpenCode/JavaScript/path-policy/queue-owner and all later organization/exact-artifact/consolidated-workflow suites are skipped; there are no executed DB/OIDC/runtime-review steps in this exact job. Earlier wording mentioning those steps is withdrawn. #45 source and #46 child authority remain unchanged; no partial adoption or wake/no-op/manual rerun is authorized.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint: #45 source stays exact 6b2a8f55...; active child #46 is now exact e2284292ed83c0c957bbcdc5745ca15585f56438 with the ordinary-forward raw pg_proc.prosecdef successor. Do not partially adopt/reimplement it. Canonical .github#2106 is exact bff097e9702a094c483a31b52327bd13d7b1c9f1 on protected .github/main@6513c7a9651af887c4cb96efc2d23080da3d4b07 and remains Draft with owner-local repository-identity RED plus nonterminal exact-current gates. #45 adoption remains blocked until current prerequisite settlement, #35 acceptance, unchanged #46 native+hosted GREEN, bounded PostgreSQL 18 live differential, and fresh child acceptance.
seonghobae
left a comment
seonghobae
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Coordination checkpoint — source head remains intentionally unchanged. Active child authority is now #46 exact 12179434ec7b11e8730a6ff4892a6f3a60973c28, whose latest ordinary-forward P1 repair preserves raw pg_proc.proleakproof after the retained prosecdef predecessor. #46 has no exact-head native/hosted GREEN and its PostgreSQL 18 bounded live differential remains open. Canonical .github#2106 is exact c81e39ce040bb174c6ffb12670cadc3d0e0878a9 on protected .github/main@a9c6477d326b84411f492ba4cac29f52deebcac3, with two owner-qualified identity source corrections and nonterminal exact-current workflows still outstanding. Do not partially adopt the child; complete ordinary/non-force adoption remains gated on unchanged-head child acceptance and the live differential.
1 participant
Stacked on #6 (
codex/pr6-v3-base). This remains the Draft relation/index-partition representation owner. Source head is intentionally unchanged at6b2a8f555725dc79f60432afbc492d6005290a4a; it must not partially cherry-pick or reimplement the active Source Observation child #46.Current child authority — 2026-09-17 KST
#46
codex/pr6-v3-index-evidenceis exact12179434ec7b11e8730a6ff4892a6f3a60973c28, OPEN / Draft / mechanically mergeable. Its latest ordinary-forward P1 repair independently preserves raw PostgreSQL 18pg_proc.proleakprooffor every exact ordinary-EXCLUDEpg_operator.oprcode -> pg_procimplementation function. It is layered over the rawprosecdefpredecessor;NOT LEAKPROOFandLEAKPROOFremain distinct governed source states without inventing a leakproof-only local admission rule. Existing digest domains remain immutable.#46 still has no executed Rust 1.98 exact-head GREEN. Exact-head repository-owned PR workflow inventory is empty and its only combined status is CodeRabbit
Review skipped: draft pull request. Its PostgreSQL 18 live differential remains open and must independently readpg_operator.oprkind,oprcom,oprresult,oprcode, then exactpg_proc.prokind,prosecdef,proleakproof,prorettype,proretset,proisstrict,provolatile, andproparallel, together with retained operator-family/strategy and backing-index namespace/lifecycle/access-method/catalog controls in the same v3 source-content generation.Adoption boundary
#45 remains source-stable until #46 reaches one unchanged exact-head native+hosted terminal GREEN and the bounded live differential passes. Adoption must then be complete, ordinary/non-force, and include every valid child delta, test, fixture, contract, doctoring, and evidence. Partial adoption or source reimplementation is not authorized.
Product bootstrap #35 and canonical
ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2106remain prerequisites..github#2106is currently exactc81e39ce040bb174c6ffb12670cadc3d0e0878a9on protected.github/main@a9c6477d326b84411f492ba4cac29f52deebcac3, OPEN / Draft / mergeable. Its owner-local RED remains the two exact owner-qualified repository-identity corrections indocs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md; exact-current Security Scan, CodeQL PR, Python Security, SAST Semgrep, and Agent Review Runtime Quality CI remain nonterminal. This lane does not compete with that owner or create wake/no-op/manual-rerun evidence.Force-push, destructive rebase, self-approval, review dismissal, administrator bypass, synthetic status, copied central workflows, manual/no-op reruns, partial child adoption, and gate weakening remain prohibited.