docs(gap): refresh product-technical baseline (74 repos, live census)

[seonghobae]

Canonical baseline owner and stack

This is the canonical BandScope product/technical-baseline lane. It owns docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md and the existing executable documentation-verification surfaces carried by this PR; it does not own the repository formatter defect, generic governance parser, or product implementation lanes.

Current exact head remains e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220. The PR is explicitly stacked on canonical formatter prerequisite #1176 exact 8fe6b6d99c009527ef0bcba419e6f6debdb23c23; the formatter delta is prerequisite ancestry, not a second baseline-owned fix. Protected/released product truth remains develop@314ddeae7b775a4957594b599358c8255617eb2e. Neither this Draft nor #1176 is shipped truth.

Source authority / executable documentation

The baseline source deliberately avoids pinning mutable Draft heads as long-lived truth. Live PR/Issue state is the exact-head authority for moving work; this PR description is refreshed when a material live dependency or commercial-gap classification changes.

#968 remains the queue-control child of this baseline and must independently revalidate whenever #1116 moves. #970 remains the durable Project Persistence owner and contains only earlier #866 ancestry. #1204 remains the canonical repository-policy writer for verify_security_notes.py and its focused regression/quickcheck wiring.

Resource Admission / Project Persistence / governance handoff — refreshed 2026-09-16

#866 remains canonical Resource Admission/Decode exact 0cb51e4d042a8f4cd5742086156a307bfe1ffac6, Open / Ready / mergeable with protected required-context evidence but without a qualifying current-head non-author formal APPROVED. Required product order remains normal protected #866 merge → ordinary/non-force #970 reconciliation/revalidation → #1160 Active Player re-admission.

#970 is exact 79e7588f2c7535f044878eea544ecace94824c4e, Open / Draft / mergeable. Its durable source/final-result/derived-feature cache work remains Draft source evidence, not protected truth. It retains the hosted cache-traceability RED repair, generation-bound cache identity, durability/resource admission, and Code Quality fixes. Fresh owner review found that its later generic Security Notes parser/test lineage violated single-writer boundaries; ordinary descendants restored the checker to protected develop and removed the generic governance tests from #970's final tree.

Canonical governance #1204 is now exact 8dda972f182086e16d0152a59e76d2f081fcf2b0, Open / Draft / mergeable on protected develop. Its earlier plan/raw-HTML contracts remain represented there. The current descendant adds three bounded governance repairs: CommonMark type-2 HTML-comment termination tails can no longer expose a trailing policy heading (ad3adf... → 5251fc...); multiline inline-comment continuation cannot promote a closing-line suffix into a heading (55bbc22... → c03399...); and a later level-one section can no longer lend ### Trust boundary evidence back into an earlier level-two Security Notes section (8e42cf... → 8dda972...). #1204 remains repository-governance ownership and does not take Project Persistence semantics from #970. Its new exact-head workflows must complete independently; predecessor checks do not transfer.

The #970 MIR generation remains an integrity/reuse boundary, not an accuracy or model-provenance claim. Full checkpoint digest/signature/acquisition provenance/rights, packaged SBOM linkage, rights-cleared real decoded audio metrics, and Windows/macOS fault-injection evidence remain release/scientific acceptance work. #866 must not duplicate #970 cache/persistence ownership, and #970 must not recreate #1204 governance ownership.

Central control-plane boundary — refreshed 2026-09-16

Protected central truth is .github/main@91be6442906c7b6b4f600272c953699708394327. Canonical versioned CodeQL dispatch bootstrap owner is ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2106, last-read exact cf7fa8635e6422db35fa60b9580cb3803cd42c1a, Open / Draft / mergeable on that protected base. cf7fa863... is two ordinary commits ahead of prior source-bearing 298e6c14... with zero semantic file delta; a proposed owner-qualification regression was removed before canonical source correction and does not count as repair progress. Predecessor settlement evidence does not transfer.

The central source finding remains owned by #2106: durable cross-repository evidence identity must retain repository owner qualification. BandScope does not become a competing writer for that central document.

Protected agent_mention_router.py remains a review dispatcher. @opencode-agent, @noema-agent, and @strix-agent mentions do not become source mutation merely by appending fix or repair; BandScope does not count mention-only activity as repair progress and does not repeat review mentions to manufacture activity.

Downstream producer/consumer cutover remains central owner work after protected integration. BandScope does not restore copied scanners, synthesize statuses, weaken direct protected Analyze (javascript-typescript) / Analyze (python) requirements, or manually rerun around the canonical owner.

Repository-wide commercial gaps

Keep visible at minimum: #1206 npm advisory RCA/remediation; #1208 >500 kB main JS / eager Score/PDF path; #1209 GHAS PR-comparison continuity; #1210 frontend executable coverage policy mismatch; #1129 audio-I/O licensing/format parity; #1180 immutable model distribution/signing/update rollback; #1181 pretrained-weight commercial rights; #970 exact-head persistence/cache-generation verification and packaged fault injection; #1204 governance exact-head acceptance; #1126 production HTTP/metadata-authentication/same-descriptor cryptographic promotion; rights-cleared real-audio MIR reproducibility; active-player audible authority; diagnostics/support bundle; activation; accessibility/localization parity.

The latest known immutable public release remains v0.1.3, published 2026-04-28 UTC. It is historical release evidence, not proof that current protected develop satisfies today’s commercial release gate.

Merge gate

Keep Draft. #1176 remains an unmerged prerequisite and must satisfy normal protected integration first. Exact e10cf16... must then reacquire its own terminal hosted checks and qualifying independent non-author review; #968 must independently validate its queue-control head. Product/governance prerequisites keep their own heads and evidence. No self-approval, bypass, force-push, destructive rebase, gate weakening, copied prerequisite delta, source-neutral freshness commit, or stale evidence transfer.

[coderabbitai]

Note

Reviews paused

It looks like this branch is under active development. To avoid overwhelming you with review comments due to an influx of new commits, CodeRabbit has automatically paused this review. You can configure this behavior by changing the reviews.auto_review.auto_pause_after_reviewed_commits setting.

Use the following commands to manage reviews:

• @coderabbitai resume to resume automatic reviews.
• @coderabbitai review to trigger a single review.

Use the checkboxes below for quick actions:

• ▶️ Resume reviews
• 🔍 Trigger review

📝 Walkthrough

Walkthrough

BandScope의 제품·기술 기준선과 운영 증거 문서를 갱신했습니다. 최신 census, 제품 요구사항, 병합 증거, transport 상태, 영속성 계약, 보안 경계, 품질 및 릴리스 기준을 반영했습니다.

Changes

BandScope 기준선 문서

Layer / File(s)	Summary
제품 및 배송 계약 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, docs/doctoring/product-gap-baseline-2026-09-01.md	74개 저장소의 최신 census와 BandScope backlog를 갱신했습니다. 제품 요구사항, 활성 작업 흐름, 병합 승계, historical evidence 및 source-selection authority를 기록했습니다.
도메인 및 기술 설계 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md	도메인 모델과 시스템 토폴로지를 보완했습니다. InitialSourceSelecting 및 ReplacementSourceSelecting 상태와 source 취소·실패·교체·삭제 전이를 추가했습니다. project_format_version, 원자적 교체, last-known-good recovery 및 식별자 호환성 계약을 명시했습니다.
보안 및 추적성 기준 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md	실제 오디오 acceptance, allowlisted Tauri IPC, 127.0.0.1 loopback, 입력 admission, subprocess 권한, 개인정보 redaction, UI/UX evidence, 품질·릴리스 게이트 및 traceability 기준을 갱신했습니다.

Estimated code review effort: 2 (Simple) | ~15 minutes

Merge Risk: 🟡 Moderate · up to 3f29e

The recovery state model currently leaves RecoveryFailed with no documented exit, so a failed restore can dead-end users and encode an incomplete product contract. Merge should wait until the contract defines acknowledgement to NoSource or retry behavior, with regression coverage.

🚥 Pre-merge checks | ✅ 5

✅ Passed checks (5 passed)

Check name	Status	Explanation
Docstring Coverage	✅ Passed	No functions found in the changed files to evaluate docstring coverage. Skipping docstring coverage check. Docstring coverage is scoped to functions touched by this diff. Analyzed 0 functions across 0…
Linked Issues check	✅ Passed	Check skipped because no linked issues were found for this pull request.
Out of Scope Changes check	✅ Passed	Check skipped because no linked issues were found for this pull request.
Description Check	✅ Passed	Check skipped - CodeRabbit’s high-level summary is enabled.
Title check	✅ Passed	제목은 제품-기술 기준 문서의 갱신과 74개 저장소의 실시간 census 반영이라는 주요 변경을 정확하고 간결하게 설명합니다.

✨ Finishing Touches

🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)

• Create PR with unit tests
• Commit unit tests in branch docs/gap-baseline-2026-08-31

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[seonghobae]

@opencode-agent Become the sole writer for canonical BandScope branch docs/gap-baseline-2026-08-31 only while it still resolves to exact head 00019c9ffe18bd630b14c4cd7c4ff4146def340f and protected develop still resolves to 749511c3ad4000090048718f685c6bee6b3d2c25. Apply superpowers:using-superpowers, receiving-code-review, systematic-debugging, and verification-before-completion. Immediately before writing refetch the exact head/base, the current blob of docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, and unresolved threads PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6ds6Rf, PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6ds6Sq, PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6ds6Ty, PRRT_kwDORjvEXs6duRIm; abort/adapt if the ref/blob moved. This is a BandScope-docs-only lane: do not modify central .github, foreign repos, source code, or workflows; do not create another PR, force-push, or weaken gates.

Validate every finding against fresh live evidence before editing. Current verified contradictions on this exact head include:

1. The document says the refreshed inventory is 185 open PRs but its recorded verification still says 130. Fresh GitHub pagination returns open develop PRs across pages 1 and 2, with page 3 empty and no open main PRs. Record a reproducible current inventory command/result or, if the count has moved since this comment, use the fresh actual count consistently instead of preserving 185 as a slogan.
2. §6 says docs has no Mermaid/sequence/class diagrams immediately before embedding two Mermaid diagrams itself; the review also notes existing doctoring Mermaid flowcharts. Replace the repository-wide absence claim with the narrower truthful gap (for example, no canonical comprehensive UML/C4/domain/state-model set, if fresh search supports that) and preserve existing diagrams as evidence rather than pretending they do not exist.
3. P1 misroutes loop playback to Issue [Release] Ship signed, notarized, auto-updatable desktop builds with rollback evidence #960. Fresh issue authority: [Release] Ship signed, notarized, auto-updatable desktop builds with rollback evidence #960 is signed/notarized/updater/release/rollback; [Product] Add an active rehearsal player with precise looping and role controls #961 owns active rehearsal player/transport/precise loops/role controls. The adjacent crash-safe project row is also shifted: [Reliability] Add a versioned crash-safe project format, autosave, migration and recovery #962 owns crash-safe/versioned project format; [Operations] Build redacted diagnostics, crash evidence and an offline support bundle #963 owns diagnostics/support bundle. Correct the issue mapping wherever the document has this off-by-one drift.
4. Revalidate live status claims rather than publishing remembered state. In particular, the Noema 120-second failure is now confirmed by consumer bandscope#1115@223d53f6c63dc17f7ce219faa52e5eafbd7719ed, required run/job 33386655858/99470699909, which reached call_llm only after sidecar/gateway preflight and then raised TimeoutError at the protected-main timeout=120 path. The canonical central owner is now open .github#1509 (fix(noema): raise call_llm HTTP timeout from 120s to org policy), exact current head 3d2b6a8262e323c794885387d1e70297b39366b5; a BandScope-local workaround is not appropriate. Also refetch refactor(engine): promote temporal probe from cli hack to api integration #1117 before repeating any exact-head test/readiness claim.

Keep the baseline a truth source rather than a blocker narrative: distinguish protected shipped truth, current live evidence, accepted/open work, and planned gaps. If correcting the document surfaces a concrete BandScope executable gap already owned by an issue/PR, link its canonical owner; do not implement that code in this docs lane. Run any repository doc/markdown/contract checks that apply plus git diff --check, commit the smallest correction on this same branch, reply with successor exact SHA and evidence, and resolve only threads whose exact claims are actually corrected on the successor head.

[seonghobae]

Concurrent recount note for the new exact head 825512fed478a1a30c60756bd21fd2599bc98f8b: every one of the 72 accessible repositories was queried individually in this cycle. Because remote agents continued opening/closing PRs during the sequential sweep, those 72 per-repository observations sum to 2,689, while the organization-wide atomic search returned 2,690 at the baseline capture and then 2,691 later in the same run. This is expected live-queue skew, not a counting contract to 'fix' by freezing writers. The rank is stable by a wide margin: BandScope 188, TEPP 142, OriginWeave 140, newsdom-api 130, naruon 127. The document's 2,690 value remains a timestamped capture rather than a timeless invariant; merge decisions continue to refetch exact live state.

[seonghobae]

@claude Please refresh the two canonical baseline files on exact current head 825512fed478a1a30c60756bd21fd2599bc98f8b through normal non-force history; do not create a competing PR. Superseding fresh evidence at 2026-09-01 17:43 KST: 73 repositories are now accessible through the connected ContextualWisdomLab GitHub account because ContextualWisdomLab/ConceptWeave is newly present; the organization-wide atomic is:pr is:open capture is 2,683. Current high-backlog counts remain bandscope 189, TEPP 149, OriginWeave 140, newsdom-api 130, naruon 125. This run exhaustively partitioned all 73 accessible repository names into GitHub issue-search groups; every non-BandScope partition was below 189, so the highest-backlog selection is proven without assuming a stale repository list. Treat all queue numbers as timestamped evidence because concurrent writers remain active. Replace the prior 72-repository/volatile-count snapshot in docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md and docs/doctoring/product-gap-baseline-2026-09-01.md without rewriting immutable PRD/TRD/DDD/UML/research contracts merely because the queue moved.

Also reconcile central-review status from fresh protected-central evidence. ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1546 remains protected truth at 5686de41660d51a7a7f22b8840dfa6ccfe5ff3f1, but the post-#1546 repository-wide scripts/ci coverage repair is still not protected truth. The current canonical root owner remains .github#1567, now exact head 400f2b5a63a5cdaf95a42ee4d49a4e492132738b. That branch now carries the scheduler coverage/SIGPIPE repair plus the history-preserved stacked #1491 Noema cleanup that removes the never-wired CodeGraph-context branch; because #1491 merged into #1567 rather than protected main, all predecessor #1567 evidence was invalidated and fresh exact-head evidence is required. Therefore central coverage remains an outstanding downstream prerequisite until #1567 itself reaches protected main. Do not revert to the obsolete claim that #1551's closure meant no coverage prerequisite remained, and do not promote #1567/#1491 candidate behavior to protected truth.

Keep the existing Rust core-computation ownership, bounded CPU/accelerator boundary, real-audio acceptance, 100% coverage/docstring/edge-case target, Storybook/Figma/screenshot UX contract, security/operability baseline, and APA 7 traceability intact. Update only truthful volatile evidence and directly contradicted status prose. Run the documentation/baseline contract tests and git diff --check, report the resulting exact head, and do not self-approve, force-push, weaken gates, or transfer predecessor evidence.

[seonghobae]

Exact-head follow-up for e1364f9d76e74a8c5e16756893205fb140f16aa3: the previously recorded code-current baseline finding is repaired in source.

Verified delta:

• Section 2 no longer calls protected dynamic Analyze (...) contexts retired or treats #1172 as a simple context-name migration; it separates dynamic protected checks from central .github#2040 compatibility settlement.
• The workstream table and §7.3 now state that #970 contains only earlier #866 ancestry and must wait for normal protected #866 merge before ordinary reconciliation/revalidation.
• #1208/#1209/#1210 and the current CodeQL rollout boundary are visible in the owning baseline.

Dependent single-writer stack was also repaired rather than left divergent: #968 advanced by ordinary two-parent commit b02cab2ad7ebfdfceaa4b172874772788f1e6410 with prior queue head first and this #1116 head second; force=false. Fresh #1116→#968 compare is behind_by=0, exactly 22 queue-owned files, with docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md absent from the delta.

This COMMENT closes only the source-authority finding. It is not approval: e1364f9d... is a new #1116 head with fresh workflows currently queued/in progress, and b02cab2... is likewise a new #968 head whose predecessor evidence cannot transfer. Keep both Draft until their own exact-head gates/reviews are terminal.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority delta: central #2040 is no longer diverged from .github/main; exact 798a5d4f2ceaf6ccc263c87b3f1d9f5e9f97bcbd is ordinary non-force 149-ahead/0-behind ancestry over protected main@691fb789.... However its fresh exact-head Runtime Quality run 34686471090 now has a causal RED: branch agent-review-runtime-quality-ci.yml executes tests/test_javascript_materializer_docstrings.py, which is absent from both current #2040 and protected main. Commit history 9b8f32ab313bc367cb21b5066cbfa2fce62d99ab proves that test originally enforced explanatory multiline docstrings on scripts/ci/materialize_base_javascript_packages.py and was introduced together with the workflow hook. Treat this as incomplete semantic preservation on #2040 and require current-contract restore/adaptation or verified successor evidence, then fresh exact-head checks. #2105’s old-handler bootstrap cycle remains a distinct prerequisite. BandScope #866 remains Ready 0cb51e4d..., 14/14 local required GREEN, but central settlement is not current.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority refresh — central CodeQL chain

Keep this as the canonical baseline lane; no baseline source commit is created by this bookkeeping update.

The prior body text naming .github#2040@798a5d4... and .github#2105@a5ca9f1c... is stale. Current live authority is:

• protected central main fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0;
• handler-bootstrap #2105 exact fde889ad611054cad0c1be5a14289b7eb881b124, ordinarily reconciled onto that protected tip, Ready but with fresh hosted runs still nonterminal and no qualifying independent approval yet;
• combined producer/handler #2040 exact 85522306949bada2b5939608dc911f6374125f1b, same base, Draft; all current non-CodeQL quality/security lanes queried are GREEN, while CodeQL PR 34686930801 remains terminal FAILURE and protected dispatch 34687138251 remains queued;
• fresh #2105 -> #2040 compare is diverged, so #2040 has not inherited #2105 by ancestry.

Commercial dependency order remains handler-first, but now with exact current identities: normal protected #2105 integration -> ordinary/non-force #2040 reconciliation to the resulting protected main -> fresh producer/protected-handler canary -> BandScope downstream settlement -> #866 merge-gate revalidation. Preserve #1206/#1208/#1209/#1210/#1211/#1129/#1180/#1181 as existing buyer/commercial gaps. Do not convert queued dispatches or direct BandScope Analyze success into central settlement, and do not duplicate central workflow logic in BandScope.

[seonghobae]

Fresh central-dependency authority correction for the next canonical gap-baseline reconciliation (no #1116 source write requested here): .github#2105@fde889ad... is now a preservation predecessor; the active first-integration owner is .github#2106@24bb6591ab7df23558cb793b4af60c567ff9da97 on protected main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0. #2106 is Ready/mergeable but not merge-ready: exact-head required opencode-review failed closed because a current-head verdict was absent while protected-main OpenCode dispatches remained pending/queued; protected CodeQL dispatch is likewise queued. After normal protected #2106 integration, .github#2040@85522306949bada2b5939608dc911f6374125f1b must ordinary/non-force reconcile that protected tip and produce fresh producer/handler + BandScope downstream settlement. #866 remains unchanged Ready/unmerged pending that settlement and a qualifying current-head non-author approval. Please absorb this sequence in the next #1116 owner source reconciliation rather than copying central workflow logic into BandScope.

[seonghobae]

Fresh central-owner correction for the canonical gap baseline; no #1116 source write in this lane.

.github#1563 is no longer safely describable only as a parallel Strix owner. Current protected central truth is main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0; #1563 current head is 20913979589d86ad1e2d26705ffb2c4a675409bd, and a fresh compare is diverged: 32 ahead / 45 behind with merge base 7fd571db.... GitHub reports it mergeable=false; its body Exact state is stale, and current-head OpenCode still has CHANGES_REQUESTED because Noema/Strix were not clean.

I converted #1563 back to Draft/Proposed and routed an ordinary non-force reconciliation finding to that canonical owner. Preserve this as a parallel central prerequisite: it must adopt/read the 45 intervening protected-main commits, refresh its exact-state authority, and regenerate current-head gates/review before its Strix classifier/evidence delta can be integrated. Do not copy the Strix gate into BandScope and do not treat predecessor #1563 checks as current evidence.

[seonghobae]

Code-current central-authority correction for the canonical gap baseline lane (source head unchanged e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220): the PR body currently calls .github#2115@a6d70b... the canonical OpenCode telemetry owner, but live .github#2106 authority identifies #2114 as canonical adapter/telemetry owner and keeps #2115 open until unique delta carryover is proven. #2114 is under an active central writer and advanced repeatedly during this run (442216bd... → 2b0b52b... → latest observed 4e68a81542825d39f5ee83c2119e19dcc53a7b90); do not transfer predecessor checks/reviews and re-fetch the live ref immediately before promotion. #2115 remains a separate Draft preservation lane. Preserve both until ordinary integration or complete mechanical succession is proven. Downstream order remains central review-infrastructure convergence -> unchanged #2106 Noema/Strix/OpenCode revalidation + qualifying approval -> normal protected #2106 integration -> #2040 ordinary reconciliation/canary -> BandScope settlement -> #866 merge-gate revalidation. Do not make #1116 a second central-workflow writer.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority correction without touching this Draft source: .github#2115 is no longer the live OpenCode telemetry owner. #2115 exact 76ca9f83f4538d33f7219b35e46646b459b37c63 is closed/unmerged only after verified complete successor carryover into canonical .github#2114.

Current central state to carry on the next canonical baseline source update: .github#2114@87510bbb623edf08dcf4acd555cd2ac9321ac6c6 is Open/Draft/mergeable on protected main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0. Its exact-head Security Scan 34703581703 is a real deterministic RED in Gitleaks job 103579501207: full commit-range scan finds exactly two historical synthetic generic-api-key fixtures (tests/test_opencode_failure_envelope.py:285, tests/test_opencode_model_pool_runner.py:638), the test-classification filter removes 0, SARIF upload succeeds, and final secret enforcement fails. Current .gitleaks.toml removed the old dedicated two-path exception while immutable RED history retains the synthetic literal, so unchanged rerun cannot repair this and history rewriting is forbidden. #2114 now owns a narrow provenance/history classification root fix that must keep real-secret controls fail-closed and reacquire fresh hosted evidence.

.github#1563@20913979589d86ad1e2d26705ffb2c4a675409bd is still 32 ahead / 45 behind / diverged from protected central main and remains the separate Strix reconciliation lane. .github#2040@85522306949bada2b5939608dc911f6374125f1b remains Open/Draft/mergeable pending normal #2106 protected integration.

The code-current dependency order for the next baseline edit is therefore: #2114 security-history repair + #1563 ordinary/non-force Strix reconciliation → unchanged #2106 review-gate revalidation + qualifying approval → normal protected #2106 merge → #2040 ordinary reconciliation/fresh canary → BandScope downstream settlement → #866 merge-gate revalidation. Keep this lane Draft and do not duplicate central source/config here.

[seonghobae]

Dependency authority update only; keep baseline source/Draft state unchanged. .github#2114 has advanced to exact bb183e4d73191c019d3470a9900f6d838078430d, 62 ahead / 0 behind protected .github/main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0. Exact-head Runtime Quality, CodeQL, Security, Python Security, and SAST were GREEN and all inline threads resolved before the unchanged source head was promoted Draft → Ready. That admission has generated a fresh central Security/CodeQL/Python/SAST + Noema/Strix generation; it is nonterminal and there is no qualifying independent current-head approval yet.

Treat prior #2114@3c43dd... Draft/CodeQL-RED wording as stale. Current order for this baseline remains #2114 fresh review-plane convergence + canonical Strix repair in #1563 → unchanged #2106 review revalidation/approval → protected #2106 merge → #2040 ordinary reconcile/canary → BandScope downstream settlement → #866 gate recheck. Do not introduce central workflow source into this BandScope docs owner.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority correction (2026-09-13): the central review-infrastructure section is stale at .github#2114@bb183e4d.... Live .github#2114 is now exact 5fb9c987c32620da63546fe69335b58f3a230cad, Open / Ready / mergeable, after two ordinary descendants from bb183e4d...: RED af6de738fae33055039acabc400b0dde9f2561b0 reproduces reviewed failure-envelope authority gaps, then GREEN candidate 5fb9c987... preserves protocol layers in failure authority. The delta is confined to the canonical OpenCode failure-envelope parser and a focused review-regression test file.

Because the source head changed, the prior bb183e4d... Runtime/Security/CodeQL/OpenCode evidence must not be transferred. Fresh current-head checks are underway; latest observation has Bandit GREEN and CodeQL Actions/Python plus Strix still in progress. Keep #1116 Draft on #1176 and do not add a BandScope fallback or documentation/source-neutral retrigger. Current causal order remains #2114 fresh generation/review + #1563 non-force reconciliation → #2106 review-plane revalidation/approval → protected #2106 integration → #2040 reconcile/canary → BandScope settlement → #866 gate recheck.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority correction, no baseline-source mutation: the .github#2114 section in the current body is stale. Live canonical review-telemetry owner is exact e7c58c04ed7e59c23cbe4a5f38d4c522ae712712, an ordinary descendant of the older bb183e4d... state. Exact-head Runtime Quality 34716210506, Security 34716210462, Python Security 34716210535, SAST 34716210489, and CodeQL 34716210555 are now terminal GREEN. The current OpenCode CHANGES_REQUESTED receipt was generated while its deterministic fallback still saw peer checks failed/pending; it reports no new source/parser finding. One unchanged-head re-review has been requested after the clean peer-check rollup.

Keep the dependency order as: #2114 independent current-head review convergence + #1563 protected-main ordinary reconciliation → #2106 24bb6591... review-plane revalidation/approval → normal protected #2106 integration → #2040 855223069... ordinary reconciliation and fresh canary → BandScope downstream settlement → #866 final merge-gate recheck. #2115 stays closed/unmerged as verified predecessor carryover only; its checks/reviews do not transfer.

This PR remains Draft at e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220 and continues to consume #1176 as a mutable prerequisite. No central implementation is copied into BandScope.

[seonghobae]

Superseding baseline dependency correction, no BandScope source mutation: existing .github#2125 / active repair .github#2126@51299f1a4398ce8481d14bbb0515dd5367aefaee is the canonical owner for stale same-head OpenCode peer-check fallbacks. #2114@e7c58c04... is now a second exact canary: source/security/CodeQL checks are terminal GREEN, yet a fresh unchanged-head review request reached Required PR Review Merge Scheduler 34718967679 and was blocked by the old current-head peer-check-only CHANGES_REQUESTED receipt. #2126 is designed to redispatch only that recognized stale fallback while preserving genuine source-level REQUEST_CHANGES.

#2126 itself still requires current-head convergence: its Noema job failed at the gateway after 1623.7s with HTTP 502 despite successful orchestrator/free preflight, and one targeted retry of that failed job was issued at the owner. Current OpenCode also awaits an authenticated exact-head verdict. Keep baseline dependency order as #2126 protected integration → #2114 unchanged-head review settlement + #1563 reconciliation → #2106 24bb6591... review-plane approval/integration → #2040 fresh reconciliation/canary → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate recheck. This PR remains Draft at e10cf16a..., with #1176 still its mutable prerequisite; do not copy central scheduler code into BandScope.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority correction — 2026-09-13

Replace the stale #2114 → #2106 review-infrastructure sequence in the body with the current live owner chain. .github#2126@51299f1a4398ce8481d14bbb0515dd5367aefaee is now the canonical same-head fallback-receipt repair for #2125 and is Open/Ready/mergeable. Exact-head CodeQL, Security, Python Security and SAST are GREEN. Its current OpenCode change request cites Noema run 34707140933; exact job evidence shows the failure occurs only after live-head/credential checks and contextual-orchestrator sidecar provisioning, at model-verdict preparation. The uploaded sidecar evidence resolves this as provider timeout/502 after healthy route discovery rather than a #2126 source finding. A single targeted rerun of failed job 103621703488 is now attempt 3 on the same head and is queued; no further retrigger or source-neutral commit is warranted while nonterminal.

Current central dependency order: #2126 same-head review settlement → protected integration → unchanged #2114 re-review + #1563 ordinary/non-force reconciliation → unchanged #2106 review revalidation/qualifying approval → normal #2106 merge → #2040 ordinary reconciliation/fresh canary → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate recheck. Keep #1116 Draft on #1176; none of these central checks/reviews transfer to e10cf16....

Separate BandScope UI consolidation in this sweep: duplicate Slider preservation PRs #1207 and #1214 were closed unmerged only after file-level complete-succession proof into canonical Draft #1188; both carried the foreign #1176 formatter delta and no unique valid Slider source/test/story contract remained. #1188 remains the single Slider owner and stays Draft.

[seonghobae]

Central prerequisite authority update only; no baseline-source delta is needed here.

Fresh .github#2126@51299f1a4398ce8481d14bbb0515dd5367aefaee Noema attempt 3 proved the consumed review runtime is still the stale .github sidecar pin contextual-orchestrator@414f22973658c4ddc3d4320fcf7acd9b4e8ba991: the exact-head artifact reaches four ready routes but repeatedly terminates provider calls at ~90 seconds and ends 502 provider_connection_error. Protected CO is now main@012beaacd0631f8cd3391c77744eeb626269b5de; however it still has no immutable GitHub Release, so mutable-main pinning is not an acceptable shortcut.

Keep the baseline's dependency order code-current as: CO immutable release owner #1030 ordinary reconciliation/publication -> central released-identity/gateway-only consumer migration .github#1759 -> unchanged #2126 review revalidation -> existing #2114/#1563 -> #2106 -> #2040 settlement -> BandScope downstream settlement -> #866 final gate. #1176 remains this baseline stack's formatter prerequisite; do not duplicate that delta or central review code into #1116.

[seonghobae]

Baseline owner-path correction: before CO #1030 can publish the immutable contextual-orchestrator release consumed by central review infrastructure, foundation packaging PR contextual-orchestrator#995 must land normally.

#995 is now exact 29b7f5457ee6a9c2a1f25f1e564f798d419bacc9, Ready, and ordinarily reconciled to protected main@012beaacd0631f8cd3391c77744eeb626269b5de with 10 ahead / 0 behind and exactly five semantic files. Fresh hosted governance has been triggered for this head. The immutable upstream fast-mlsirm v0.9.1 Release resolves to 09f762ded35786dd1078222a4577ff09d649816f, the same source commit protected main temporarily consumed through #1111; #995 therefore converts the temporary commit-pin recovery into the released contract while enforcing Python >=3.12.

Current CO release owner #1030 is b51009c8b5b6c9e79672e412a87e5b4609f42173, Draft. It still descends from #995 predecessor e2df7803...; relative to reconciled #995 it is diverged (34 ahead / 176 behind). Preserve #1030 until #995 reaches protected main, then ordinary/non-force reconcile and reacquire exact-head release/signing/SBOM/review evidence. No predecessor evidence transfer.

For BandScope dependency accounting, prepend this foundation sequence before the previously recorded central review chain: CO #995 normal merge → CO #1030 non-force reconciliation + immutable release → .github released-identity consumer migration (#1759) → unchanged #2126 revalidation → #2114/#1563 → #2106 → #2040 → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate. BandScope source and this baseline source remain unchanged.

[seonghobae]

Central authority correction for the baseline; no #1116 source movement.

Fresh canary contextual-orchestrator#995@29b7f5457ee6a9c2a1f25f1e564f798d419bacc9 proves protected .github coverage currently rejects a legitimate changed uv.lock before pytest via merged_base_fingerprint_drift (OpenCode dispatch 34730081810, coverage job 103651431338). Canonical owner is .github#1398 (fix(coverage): trust validated Python head locks). Its live head 8ff7cc0969860a1473a57bbfe500ce3a023a41be is 20 ahead / 87 behind protected .github/main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0, mergeable=false, and is now Draft pending ordinary/non-force reconciliation and fresh validation.

Baseline dependency order is therefore .github#1398 integration → unchanged CO #995 exact-head coverage/review replay and normal merge → CO #1030 current-main reconciliation + immutable release → .github #1759 released-gateway consumer migration → unchanged #2126 revalidation → #2114/#1563 → #2106 → #2040 → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate. Keep this baseline Draft; do not copy the central materializer or gateway into BandScope and do not treat predecessor checks/reviews as current evidence.

[seonghobae]

Central authority correction for the baseline; no #1116 source movement.

The prior .github#1398 → CO #995 front is now missing an intervening current-main materializer owner. Fresh live state: .github#2094@21afaac70b52866ffed6ada3411e07b35a583cb1 is based directly on protected .github/main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0 (2 ahead / 0 behind, Open / Ready / mergeable) and modifies both scripts/ci/materialize_base_python_requirements.py and its focused tests to fail closed on incompatible exact uv toolchains. Its current exact-head Security/Python Security/SAST/Trusted-uv/CodeQL generation is still queued.

Baseline dependency order is therefore .github#2094 exact-head settlement/integration → .github#1398 ordinary/non-force reconciliation preserving #2094 plus the CO #995 changed-lock canary → unchanged CO #995 coverage/review replay + normal merge → CO #1030 current-main reconciliation + immutable release → .github#1759 released-gateway consumer migration → #2126 → #2114/#1563 → #2106 → #2040 → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate.

Keep #1116 Draft. Do not copy central materializer/runtime source into BandScope, and do not treat any predecessor checks/reviews as evidence for a reconciled exact head.

[seonghobae]

Baseline central-head correction; #1116 remains Draft with no source movement.

.github#2094 advanced by ordinary review repair to exact fdb26595641ff515b1cf27bd6e149ca8137f4f1a, 4 ahead / 0 behind protected .github/main@fb17ef556f94f673234aa557254ae52779e9a7b0. The valid current-head finding was in its Strix hash-lock coverage test: extras-bearing direct requirements were omitted and a valid single-line pin form could be rejected. The same owner now carries focused extras and multiline/single-line regressions; CodeRabbit marked the finding resolved/outdated. Fresh exact-head Trusted-uv/CodeQL/security runs are still queued/pending and no predecessor evidence transfers.

Current dependency front: .github#2094 settlement/integration → #1398 ordinary/non-force reconciliation preserving #2094 plus the CO #995 changed-lock canary → unchanged CO #995 replay/normal merge → CO #1030 immutable release → .github#1759 → #2126 → #2114/#1563 → #2106 → #2040 → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate. Keep central materializer source out of BandScope.

[seonghobae]

Live baseline correction after intervening ordinary descendant; no #1116 source movement.

.github#2094 current exact head is 2a8e540cf6c921d457e7ae75299d6e930f578cbd, one ordinary descendant after fdb2659.... It preserves the extras-bearing direct-requirement and multiline/single-line lock repair, then tightens the test to reuse the canonical materializer's logical requirement/hash validation and reject un-hashed or malformed-hash entries. Adopt this stronger current owner state; do not replay the predecessor test helper. Fresh exact-head Trusted-uv/CodeQL/security runs are queued and predecessor evidence is non-passing.

Dependency order remains #2094 settlement/integration → #1398 ordinary/non-force reconciliation preserving #2094 + CO #995 canary → CO #995 → CO #1030 immutable release → .github#1759 → #2126 → #2114/#1563 → #2106 → #2040 → BandScope settlement → #866 final gate.

[seonghobae]

Central prerequisite correction for the baseline: protected ContextualWisdomLab/.github/main advanced to 64f483db9d052322c65bcdf1675d66138156f306. Trusted-uv owner #2094 was therefore stale at 2a8e540c... (5 ahead / 12 behind). I preserved both histories with an ordinary two-parent merge and non-force fast-forward; #2094 is now exact 5f90b418187482e7eee1d295d09145e899853925, 6 ahead / 0 behind current protected main, and its semantic diff is still exactly the same six files (+294/-24). Fresh exact-head gates are queued, so predecessor checks/reviews do not count.

Keep this baseline Draft. Central order is #2094 fresh gates/review + protected integration → #1398 ordinary reconciliation → unchanged CO #995 replay/merge → CO #1030 immutable release → .github#1759 → #2126 → #2114/#1563 → #2106 → #2040 → BandScope settlement. #1116 remains exact e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220 stacked on #1176; do not copy central materializer logic or manufacture freshness here.

[seonghobae]

Central prerequisite correction for the BandScope baseline: .github#2094@5f90b418187482e7eee1d295d09145e899853925 reproduced the protected CodeQL split-wake race with clean native language scans. The canonical handler repair is .github#2106, so #2106 must land before #2094 can obtain final required-CodeQL settlement.

#2106 has now been ordinary/non-force reconciled onto protected .github/main@64f483db9d052322c65bcdf1675d66138156f306: exact head 611ccd73460ab0188e0085956ade6180bb28a91a is the verified two-parent merge of current main and prior canonical #2106 head 24bb6591ab7df23558cb793b4af60c567ff9da97. Fresh exact-head central generations are queued, so historical checks/reviews do not transfer and no merge is claimed.

Current dependency order: #2106 fresh protected settlement -> unchanged #2094 replay -> #1398 materializer reconciliation -> CO #995 -> immutable CO #1030 release -> central released-consumer/review settlement -> #2040 v2 producer/consumer restack/canary -> BandScope downstream settlement -> #866 final gate. This replaces the prior cyclic ordering that put #2106 after #2094. Keep this baseline Draft and do not copy central CodeQL/review machinery into BandScope.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority correction, 2026-09-13:

Keep this PR Draft at unchanged e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220, stacked on #1176 8fe6b6d99c009527ef0bcba419e6f6debdb23c23. Do not move the baseline source merely to refresh hosted evidence.

The central section in the current document/body is stale. Live protected .github/main is 64f483db9d052322c65bcdf1675d66138156f306; canonical CodeQL handler bootstrap .github#2106 is exact 611ccd73460ab0188e0085956ade6180bb28a91a, Open/Ready/mergeable after ordinary non-force reconciliation.

Current exact #2106 evidence adds two owner findings that the next legitimate baseline source update must preserve:

• CodeQL required run 34742112070 dispatched a protected-handler tuple carrying stale base fb17ef55...; handler 34742687277 failed closed at live PR/base binding before any scan because the live base is now 64f483db.... One coordinator-only replay is queued on the unchanged head; failed compatibility shards were not directly rerun.
• Required Noema failed during CO sidecar provisioning, before model verdict, with 24 candidates / 16 probes / ready_count=0 (429/404 plus one ~90 s timeout). Strix subsequently provisioned the CO sidecar successfully, so one targeted Noema failed-job retry is queued; no provider/model override or paid fallback was added.

Until those central lanes and a qualifying current-head review settle, this Draft must not translate central intermediate state into shipped BandScope truth. The product gaps already recorded—actual-audio/browser/AT/locale acceptance, crash-safe persistence, real-audio MIR reproducibility, licensing, signing/notarization and updater rollback—remain open.

[seonghobae]

Baseline dependency correction, no source movement on e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220:

Central .github#2106 is now exact 611ccd73460ab0188e0085956ade6180bb28a91a on protected main@64f483db9d052322c65bcdf1675d66138156f306. Current repository-owned code/security gates are GREEN and the correct-base CodeQL handler canary reproduces the legacy per-language wake race that #2106 removes.

Its current Strix failure is not evidence that the seven-path CodeQL delta contains the two reported policy vulnerabilities. GitHub's authoritative #2106 changed set excludes both scripts/ci/pingora_edge_policy.py and scripts/ci/contextual_orchestrator_review_policy.py; the Strix fallback scan workspace widened attribution after a merge-base failure and then reported those support-file findings as changed-file intersections. Exact repair evidence is now on canonical Strix owner .github#1563; the underlying Pingora and legacy provider-routing findings are preserved on .github#1952 and .github#1759 respectively.

Until those central owners integrate and unchanged #2106 review checks are replayed cleanly, keep this baseline Draft. Do not encode the central scanner/provider policy into BandScope documentation as shipped truth and do not transfer predecessor review evidence.

[seonghobae]

Baseline authority correction without source movement (e10cf16aabf47d4370f25d0a98509dca0d11b220 remains Draft on formatter prerequisite #1176).

The current central Strix chain is more specific than the body snapshot: .github#939 owns authenticated/bounded PR-source identity and changed-file attribution; .github#1563 owns terminal attempt/report/SARIF and recovered-transient evidence semantics. This split follows fresh source inspection: both current changed-file arrays are populated from the same merge-base/direct-diff fallback, so a naming-only array substitution would not repair the #2106 production canary. #939 is now Draft at 0db992904dd4be91e1faae01bab3a6ff8ba01e3d, 35 ahead / 93 behind protected .github/main@64f483db9d052322c65bcdf1675d66138156f306, and must preserve its valid scope delta through ordinary/non-force reconciliation. #1563 remains Draft/diverged and must preserve its evidence-classification delta separately.

The concrete Pingora canary is current .github#2149@97697a481790a1fd5699802498e77eaa5c893328; do not route it to historical #1952. The released contextual-orchestrator consumer path remains central ownership.

For the baseline, record the dependency order as #939 + #1563 + released-CO prerequisites → unchanged #2106 review replay/approval → normal #2106 integration → #2040 ordinary reconciliation/fresh producer-handler canary → BandScope settlement. This is documentation authority only; no central workflow or policy source belongs in BandScope.