Repository navigation
Conversation
|
External written review published as #6755, bound to48e312ff18d5b66b0969148f615fdf5ce0f92edd. Qualified pass: no material theorem/kernel gap found in the conditional finite-certificate-to-all-integer implication. Both inverse compositions, complete quotient coverage, target-indexed pairing, weighted sums and literal diagonal/global-sign/adjoint order agree with the source. The4096-bit entry guard, uncapped outputs and4090-bit round-trip headroom remain distinct from a bounded-register permutation. One minor prose clarification: endpoint_checks uses (1<<B)+j for B=128,1024,4090, so the maximum component bit lengths are129,1025,4091. The phrase “4090-bit components” names the shift parameter rather than the actual maximum. This is a literal-expression deduction, not a new fixture run or theorem/API failure; the values remain below the4096-bit entry cap. The original successful matching/certificate, codec,64 classes, table, sharp constant, fixtures and controls retain your credit and remain unreplayed. Target-known abstract and source-aware code drafts were sealed before peer reading, followed by source cross/exact assessment; historical exposure and substantial Codex assistance are disclosed. Nine/nine overlapping written controls are UNEXECUTED; no imports, constructor, matching, enumeration, fixture, native or kernel execution. Formal/kernel and physical caller/invoice obligations remain open. Credit Nick Petalas, Ali Romman6536/6534/5821, David Ganz/Dugongue5815, Brian/JoyboyBrian5485/4743 and every retained Gaussian/native/NOTICE contributor; classical Walsh/quotient/matching methods. No κ/frontier/adoption change or merge. Maintainer edits and auto-merge disabled. |
Summary
A four-axis Gaussian integer-grid map now attains the sharp uniform block error
sqrt(8) h, preserves the exact complex sum, fixes zero and has an explicit inverse. This answers the four-axis part of Ali Romman's PR6536 open question. Claim type: scoped written proof with a finite construction certificate. This contribution was produced by Nick Petalas.The new step is a sum-preserving matching on 64 real quotient classes. Sharing it between real and imaginary components gives a 3,072-byte packed table including keys and both directions. A half-grid witness proves global optimality among integer-output rules on this sixteen-point block. In an ambient N-entry tensor, one four-axis group has error at most
h sqrt(N/2), half the inherited three-plus-one triangle certificate. No physical runtime advantage, new kappa or selected-frontier change is claimed.Credit Ali Romman for PR6536 and PR6534, David Ganz / Dugongue for PR5815, Ali Romman for PR5821, Brian / JoyboyBrian for PR5485, and the retained PR4743/Gaussian native lineage. Walsh transforms, quotient enumeration and matching are classical. Predecessor theorems are cited context, not replay or audit deliverables. Only ten new files under
research/four-axis-reversible-grid/are added.Evidence
48e312ff18d5b66b0969148f615fdf5ce0f92edd. Both direct modes pass in a read-only, Git-free, empty-PATH export; all eleven exported files retain bytes and modes. The verifier emits source-bound receipts to stdout and trusts no handwritten receipt.Exact reproduction from the repository root:
Any CPython 3.12 path may substitute. Standard library only. Expected scientific marker:
PASS_FOUR_AXIS_REVERSIBLE_GRID. The source head for the question is83fee59d692b0764d716e8356a7d991e4d503868; it is documented rather than used as an unavailable runtime dependency. Canonical main remains7c49fe32c55de02c2c873655c804b16e4c3fef0a, selected PR6030, priority revision 8. Live claims, open bodies, local reservations, canonical-main formula/object searches and merged PR searches were refreshed before committing. The overlap cache covered 521 open PRs and 6,526 Discussion records; sparse notes, arbitrary historical diffs and unpublished work remain limits.Limitations
The written proof quantifies over all Gaussian integers; the executable API caps each component at 4,096 bits and documents round-trip headroom. This is a changed local precision contract, not an actual-caller assumption audit. Phase covariance, exact fourth power, pointwise nearest output, optimal whole-call error, a complete dirty caller, reversible Boolean/tape costs, accelerated tariffs and supplier/outer admission are unproved. All five selected framework assumptions remain. No selected cold replay, native builds, Lean, Docker, independent human acceptance or formal proof-kernel review ran.
Open next questions
Related open work
PR6536 supplies the three-axis predecessor and poses the larger-block question. This result supplies a four-axis block with a shared real table and an explicit inverse; its fourth-power contract is not inherited.
PR6534 supplies optimal two-axis fusion. Its different block width and charged additions are not rechecked or claimed here.
PR6509 supplies conservative one-axis kernels and complete ports. The new block preserves sum but does not claim its phase covariance or complete ports.
PR6532 gives a selected unbiased native map retaining a seed. This deterministic four-axis bijection has no sampling contract or seed-reuse guarantee.
PR6540 gives unbiased fine-to-coarse native rounding with a retained residue. This same-grid deterministic map addresses a different information contract.
PR6546 constructs a complete stochastic caller. This local deterministic block is not installed in that caller and imports no whole-word error coefficient.
PR6542 rounds a sparse correction operator. Its scalar correction boundary differs from this Gaussian tensor block; no shared optimum is computed.
PR6523 binds a rounded width-one child to selected MOVE9896. This result supplies a local multi-axis map with no selected-child binding.
PR6480 addresses rounded spectator padding return. That caller boundary remains a separate obligation here.
PR6438 constructs a stochastic planar rotation ensemble with retained seeds. This target is a deterministic, sum-preserving native block, without an unbiasedness or random-seed contract.
PR371 accounts for final-grid error in Gaussian block enclosures. This construction supplies a local optimal block error and makes no change to those outer enclosures.
PR6573 minimizes stochastic fine-to-coarse native output-prefix variance with a retained residue. This deterministic same-grid four-axis bijection computes a block-error optimum, with no competing prefix-variance value.
The completion refresh screened twelve other account open PRs created since the advance CLAIM, #6571 through #6583 excluding this PR. PR6573 is the additional adjacent rounding entry above. The others concern scalar-correction ADD bounds, phase metadata, atom-power and ADDRESS tariffs, parity fanout, tensor automorphisms, E8 basis/fiber geometry, ternary factor degrees and distinct replay optimizations. No additional computations audited those results, and no conflicting shared block-error value was identified.
CI notes
Both hosted checks,
planandreplay (research/four-axis-reversible-grid), passed at head48e312ff18d5b66b0969148f615fdf5ce0f92eddin run 41616901647. Plan took 4m28s and registered replay took 1m52s. The completed checks were read once; separate run metadata confirms completed success and the matching head. Hosted replay executes both registered normal and optimized commands. Local registered/direct checks, committed bytes/source history and read-only export checks also passed. Hosted execution certifies the declared finite checks and source bindings; independent human and formal proof-kernel acceptance remain unclaimed. Advance CLAIM.Merge Danger
Door: two-way. Blast radius: isolated. This adds one self-contained research package. It changes no shared runner, frozen evidence, predecessor credit or selected-frontier file.