Skip to content

Prove the root hub of P104 chain-nested roots is forced under replay: single-time, piece-adjacent and commuting-split scalings (no κ) - #6859

Open
DreamingOfClouds wants to merge 1 commit into
CrocSwap:mainfrom
DreamingOfClouds:research/p104-root-hub-forcing
Open

DreamingOfClouds wants to merge 1 commit into
CrocSwap:mainfrom
DreamingOfClouds:research/p104-root-hub-forcing

Conversation

@DreamingOfClouds

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

No κ claim. This adds research/p104-root-hub-forcing/, a registered research package for the card p104-side-correction.

Result. Take a saturated word W(D) = S_N T_N ... S_1 T_1 with N = n+1 shears T_j = I - 2 x_j y_j (y_j x_j = 0), characteristic 0, independent scaling parameters D_m, scalings S_e = I + (D_{s(e)} - 1) E_e with idempotent E_e, coordinate target masks M_m, and atomic LOCAL pieces (E x_p = x_p, y_p E = y_p), replaying at Q = +1 and Q = -1 with W(+1) = D^w and W(-1) = -D^w. Then some coordinate lies in every mask, so the hub target 8L+1 (= 145 on the 9|9 chain-nested root of #6833) cannot be lowered, in each of these cases:

  1. every stage is scaled at a single time;
  2. one stage is split into two pieces, with no non-local piece between a shear and the LOCAL piece of its own stage;
  3. any number of split stages and pieces whose in-window pieces of distinct stages commute.

The package also states Lemma M: the master identity is equivalent to one invertible M(D) with Lam^{-1} T_j Lam = M T_j M^{-1} for all j, confirmed exactly on the 1|1 and 2|2 chains.

Proof sketch. The master identity makes every primed Gram entry a signed monomial, and a specialisation to one stage fixes its exponent pattern (including beta = 0 for the last stage directly from orthogonality of its pieces). The top coefficient of the first-to-last entry is then a sum over one in-window piece per stage of y_N tau x_1; under the stated hypotheses every tau is supported on the common coordinates of the in-window stages, and that coefficient is nonzero.

Checks. check.py (standard library, exact rationals, under a second) verifies on chains (1|1) and (2|2): the replay, the monomial Gram with g_ij g_ji = -1, the top coefficient and the common carrier, and Lemma M. It also verifies the multilinear top-coefficient formula on random non-commuting pieces, commuting configurations, and one control that violates the commuting hypothesis, where the formula gives a nonzero coefficient with tau outside the common coordinates (not a counterexample, since the master identity is not imposed there).

Scope. Not covered, and listed as open questions: non-commuting interleaved pieces of distinct stages, the slot between the last shear and its LOCAL piece with a non-commuting first piece, non-atomic LOCAL, unsaturated headers, non-coordinate masks, and Q-dependent frame operations. One mid-slot triangle configuration (n = 4) is additionally excluded by an exact reduction, stated as a remark without a checker. No word is constructed and nothing is priced.

Prepared by DreamingOfClouds with Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic), via Claude Code.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

…(no kappa)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant