Description
Line graphs can have only one colour per series.
Sometime it is very useful to have the line colour variable based on value, to show visually ranges.
For example, I am using right now Apexcharts for energy prices and I obtain:
Why should this feature be added?
Provide information visually, without the need of reading values, which is useful when preparing graph which must be understood easily and also by less technical people.
I can open a PR if the feature is approved. It would be generated by LLM and tested myself.
Mocks/Designs
See screenshot above.
Notes
Related: #5259
This is Claude asked about the complexity of the implementation:
Area graphs: works today
Scatter traces have a fillgradient attribute (src/traces/scatter/attributes.js:387). Set it to type: 'vertical' and give start/stop in y-axis units. Colour scales accept the same position twice, so a scale can switch colour sharply instead of blending. That makes thresholds possible:
// thresholds 2 and 4, gradient spans y = 0..6
fillgradient: {
type: 'vertical', start: 0, stop: 6,
colorscale: [[0, base], [2/6, base], [2/6, 'orange'],
[4/6, 'orange'], [4/6, 'red'], [1, 'red']]
}
Lines and stepped lines: needs a new attribute
line.color takes one colour only. The drawing helper behind fillgradient (gradientWithBounds in src/components/drawing/index.js:462) can already colour a line instead of a fill. So the feature would mostly reuse existing code:
- New attributes: add them to the scatter line settings, plus their defaults in
line_defaults.js.
- Drawing: call the existing helper on the line, in the same way the fill code does.
- Other pieces:
- the legend icon;
- image tests (a human must generate the reference images);
- a changelog file in
draftlogs/;
- a rebuild of the generated schema.
It would work for all line shapes, including hv, vh, hvh, vhv and spline. It would not cover the WebGL version (scattergl), and stacked areas would be coloured by their stacked height.
For the settings, I suggest a line.gradient that copies fillgradient (type, start, stop, colorscale). That keeps the API consistent, and plotly.js puts consistency first. Your threshold list could be added on top of that as an easier way to write the stepped colour scale. The maintainers should decide on that part.
Description
Line graphs can have only one colour per series.
Sometime it is very useful to have the line colour variable based on value, to show visually ranges.
For example, I am using right now Apexcharts for energy prices and I obtain:
Why should this feature be added?
Provide information visually, without the need of reading values, which is useful when preparing graph which must be understood easily and also by less technical people.
I can open a PR if the feature is approved. It would be generated by LLM and tested myself.
Mocks/Designs
See screenshot above.
Notes
Related: #5259
This is Claude asked about the complexity of the implementation:
Area graphs: works today
Scatter traces have a
fillgradientattribute (src/traces/scatter/attributes.js:387). Set it totype: 'vertical'and givestart/stopin y-axis units. Colour scales accept the same position twice, so a scale can switch colour sharply instead of blending. That makes thresholds possible:Lines and stepped lines: needs a new attribute
line.colortakes one colour only. The drawing helper behindfillgradient(gradientWithBoundsinsrc/components/drawing/index.js:462) can already colour a line instead of a fill. So the feature would mostly reuse existing code:line_defaults.js.draftlogs/;It would work for all line shapes, including
hv,vh,hvh,vhvandspline. It would not cover the WebGL version (scattergl), and stacked areas would be coloured by their stacked height.For the settings, I suggest a
line.gradientthat copiesfillgradient(type,start,stop,colorscale). That keeps the API consistent, and plotly.js puts consistency first. Your threshold list could be added on top of that as an easier way to write the stepped colour scale. The maintainers should decide on that part.